1990 Pro Set Football: A variation paradise – pt.1

27 Nov

This post will focus on the lesser-known variations in the Dallas, TX based company’s sophmore set. 1990 Pro Set is home to a ton of well-documented variations: The New Orleans saints cards with white numbers, cards of Ray Perkins and Johnny Holland are missing their names and position on the reverse, stat errors in the text of Joe Montana’s card #2, etc…all of that info has been recorded in many places online and is usually just a click away. Tonight, I’m going to showcase some of the lesser known variations that can be found in the set.

#772 Dexter Manley backwards T. Manley’s card is already one of the most desirable error cards produced in modern trading cards. As of this writing, the last sale was for over $600. For those who don’t know, Manley’s card originally had a message about his suspension from the league due to violating the NFL’s substance abuse policy, to which Manley and his lawyer objected. According to Pro Set, just a handful slipped through before correction. Not a new story in the error card world, but what many people are just finding out, is that a third variety exists: a version of the corrected card where the ‘t’ in “Official card of the NFL” on back (at bottom) looks as though it was printed backwards, or better yet, like a ‘j’ that had it’s top crossed instead of dotted. The backwards t is also present on the original substance abuse version as well, making this card a somewhat difficult “transitional” variety. In the 55 sets I have acquired in pursuit of the ‘substance abuse’ error, I have found just one of these ‘backward t’ errors!

#134 Andre Rison with “clipped” number on back. Rison’s card is already a mess as it comes in 3-different varieties to begin with: a) No trade on front (NTOF) b) Trade on front (TOF) c) Trade on front, Message back (TOFMB). Both types that show #134 in the bottom right corner can be found with the top of the digits sliced off. My experience collecting these variations has shown a 1 error: 4 corrected for each of the (NTOF) and (TOF) types.

#134 Andre Rison (Lud Denny Message on back) signature variations: Rison’s message back card was always one of my favorite pulls as a kid. It was just weird! The president of a card company explaining themselves to me in letter form? On that back of one of the hottest young receiver’s in the league’s card?? I vaguely recall reading something back in 1990 about a version that didn’t have all of the message printed on back and I eagerly tried to find one for myself. Unfortunately, as of now, it remains in my “Urban card legends” file as I’ve yet to see or hear of another copy since. But my hunt did however, turn up a variation in this card: One variety has Lud’s signature printed so that it nearly touches his name and the word ‘sincerely’ and another has it spaced further away. I have found 1 ‘close’ version for every 10 ‘further’ copies I own.

#59 Mike Ditka large ‘Hall of Fame’ print. A fairly straight-forward one that may not entirely qualify for the ‘unknown’ title, but since it’s not cataloged in any of the annual guides, it’s worth mentioning here. Mike Ditka’s card comes in two different varieties involving the font size of the words “Hall of Fame” in the banner on front: The much rarer version has the larger font that stretches across the entire banner-usually getting cut off at the edges while the more common version is shrunk to fit with a little room around the words. I have found just 3 copies of the large print for my 90 small print ones making this, in my opinion, of course, one of the rarest pack-issued variations from 1990 Pro Set.

A few final notes of interest for 1990 Pro Set:

-The Santa Claus card is rumored to come in two different versions. I have a magazine or two from early 1991 where readers wrote in to ask about this. I own a dozen of copies of the card and they all look the same to me. The only mistake I can find is that they forgot a quotation mark after the word WARE (for Andre Ware) but I have yet to see a corrected copy. Something tells me that this isn’t why collectors thought a variation existed.  Also, the 1989 Santa is rumored as well, to have a version when there is a statistical measurement for his belly on back. Can anyone confirm this?

#719 Mike Bellamy can be found with the right arm of the Y in BELLAMY clipped off on the card front. I have found just 3 copies like this in roughly 60 copies I own.

#644 Dave Waymer is rumored to exist in a version similar to Rod Woodson and Wes Hopkins’ cards where the stat headings are printed in black instead of red. I can’t confirm this, but I can confirm that 1:3 of the copies I have found has a thin, jagged, almost hand-printed looking line under the TOTALS on back, maybe not rare but a definite variation that Pro Set took the time to change.

#343 Chris Hinton Pro Bowl card is a well-known variation due to it receiving a traded ‘snipe’ on the front. Pro Set also changed the text on back to mention his trade. A third variety may be out there that shows the trade ‘snipe’ but without the new text on back. This would likely be a very short run ‘transitional’ type card similar to the 1989 variations of Jim McMahon, Gerald Riggs and Earnest Byner. Based on my 80+ copies, I am unable to confirm this right now.

Stay tuned for a pt. 2 to the 1990 Pro Set section – there’s a lot of “mistakes” in this set.

12 Responses to “1990 Pro Set Football: A variation paradise – pt.1”

  1. Matt January 27, 2010 at 11:44 am #

    Hello!

    I just wanted to let you know that you have 346b listed as “Chris Hinton PB (With Traded Stripe, text-on-back begins “Six time Pro Bowl”

    Chris Hinton was listed as 343.

    Thanks a lot for your incredible list! My dad and I are having a blast sorting through his 1000’s of 90 Pro Set Football.

    Thanks again!

    Matt

  2. Mike January 29, 2010 at 7:57 am #

    I do have the 1990 Pro Set card#343b Chris Hinton PB trade ’snipe’ with and without the new text on back.

    • junkwaxgems January 29, 2010 at 8:14 am #

      Is the text the same as the non-trade snipe version?

  3. RICH April 20, 2011 at 6:04 pm #

    I FOUND A SHEET OF THE ANDRE RISENS WITH THE LUD DENNY EXPLAINATION ON THE BACK..DIDNT THINK MUCH OF IT AT FIRST…THEN I SAW YOURS ON THE WEB SITE…DO YOU SEE MANY? LET ME KNOW..

  4. dandrix6060 August 23, 2011 at 7:32 pm #

    Just checked my pro set cards. bought about 20 boxes from different sources 20 years ago. have approx 40 of each card.
    only 1 fred marion belt error
    only 1 chris hinton traded stripe “Has been named” version
    only 1 fred washington ( bloody face)
    only 1 roger craig (red specks on leg)
    found 8 art shell (large HOF)
    All 40 mike ditkas had (small HOF) font

    • Dylan September 11, 2011 at 7:16 pm #

      Congrats! The Hinton and Marion are tough. What birthdates on the Shell large HOF did you find?

  5. dandrix6060 September 18, 2011 at 8:06 pm #

    All 8 of the Art Shell large HOF’s have birthdate listed as 11/26/46)

  6. Dandy February 27, 2012 at 4:33 pm #

    Has anyone seen a 1990 Joe Montana with Wilber Marshall (#326) printed on the back?

    • Eric March 8, 2012 at 7:32 am #

      I am pretty sure this is one of the wrong-backs I have seen. The front of the card is one of the gold-bordered cards at the front of the set and the back is the base card of Marshall in the Redskins uniform. Am I correct on that one?

  7. Jon August 26, 2012 at 10:38 am #

    So how much are the Dexter Manley error “t” cards worth?

    • Dylan August 26, 2012 at 10:43 am #

      Like everything else, they are worth what someone is willing to pay. Check eBay completed listings for recent sales.

  8. Jeremiah Erickson August 21, 2016 at 2:40 pm #

    Found a 1990 score football printing variation #187 lonzell hill 3 of 6 had yellowish square on the right side of the name/team bar.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: